Brunel Q4 and FY 2016 results

Friday, February 24, 2017

Mixed fourth quarter in Europe; restructuring and transforming Energy

Key points Q4 2016

  • Revenue down by 27% to EUR 211 million
  • Gross margin up to 21.9% from 20.1%
  • Operating costs up by 10% to EUR 44 million
  • Operating costs include EUR 3.5 million for restructuring in Energy
  • EBIT down from EUR 18 million to EUR 2 million

Key points FY 2016

  • Revenue down by 28% at EUR 885 million
  • Gross margin at 21.1% from 18.7%
  • Operating costs down by 8% to EUR 160 million
  • EBIT down by 52% to EUR 27 million
  • Net profit at EUR 11 million
  • Proposed dividend EUR 0.40 per share

Brunel International (unaudited)

 

 

 

 

 

P&L amounts in EUR million

Q4 2016

Q4 2015

Change %

FY 2016

FY 2015

Change %

Revenue

210.6

287.2

-27% a

884.9

1,228.9

-28% b

Gross Profit

46.2

57.6

-20%

187.1

230.0

-19%

Gross Margin

21.9%

20.1%

21.1%

18.7%

Operating costs

44.1

40.0

10% c

160.3

173.9

-8% d

EBIT

2.1

17.6

-88%

26.8

56.1

-52%

EBIT %

1.0%

6.1%

3.0%

4.6%

 

Average directs

9,078

10,604

-14%

9,315

10,894

-14%

Average indirects

1,435

1,539

-7%

1,481

1,601

-7%

Ratio direct/indirect

6.3

6.9

6.3

6.8

a -27% at constant currencies                           

b -27% at constant currencies

c -9% at constant currencies

d -7% at constant currencies

Q4 2016 results

Revenue
Revenue development in Q4 in Europe appears flat year on year. However, this is composed of growth in Germany and other Europe, offset by a decrease in The Netherlands. Energy managed to achieve a slight increase compared to Q3 due to some short term projects, but still a strong decline compared to last year.

Gross Profit
As a result of the change in business mix with higher margins in Europe compared to Energy, the gross margin improved by 1.8ppt to 21.9%.

Operating Costs
Operating costs are impacted significantly in Q4 by one off restructuring and redundancy cost. Adjusted for these costs operating costs are at the same level as last year. The decrease in Energy is offset by an increase in Europe.

EBIT
EBIT in Europe dropped compared to a very strong Q4 in 2015, and also the decrease in Energy was significant. Overall EBIT decreased by 88% to EUR 2 million in the fourth quarter.

Q4 2016 results by division

Brunel Energy (unaudited)

 

 

 

 

 

P&L amounts in EUR million

Q4 2016

Q4 2015

Change %

FY 2016

FY 2015

Change %

Revenue

100.4

174.3

-42% a

447.1

813.7

-45% b

Gross Profit

11.4

20.2

-43%

49.2

96.3

-49%

Gross Margin

11.4%

11.6%

11.0%

11.8%

Operating costs

14.7

15.1

-2% c

50.8

67.3

-24% d

EBIT

-3.3

5.0

-166%

-1.6

29.0

-106%

EBIT %

-3.3%

2.9%

-0.4%

3.6%

 

Average directs

4,292

5,808

-26%

4,596

6,333

-27%

Average indirects

516

649

-21%

571

707

-19%

Ratio direct/indirect

8.3

9.0

8.0

9.0

a -44% at constant currencies

b -44% at constant currencies

c -6% at constant currencies

d -23% at constant currencies

Revenue
Revenue increased slightly compared to Q3 due to some short term projects. Year on year revenue for Q4 reduced by 42% and the decrease was felt in all regions. Australasia and Thailand were impacted mostly as a result of finished work for offshore projects. The impact of Fx differences is limited when comparing Q4 2015 to Q4 2016.

Gross Profit
The gross margin appears to remain stable compared to last year. However, this is impacted by a change in the mix. On average the decrease in headcount has been less in areas with an average higher margin. The industry is still facing margin pressure.

Operating Costs

In Q4, we have been able to finalize most of our restructuring and cost saving initiatives. This has caused EUR 3.5 million of one off expenses. We have closed or paused some of our activities in Africa and Asia. Adjusted for the one off costs operating costs in Q4 were reduced by 26% compared to Q4 2015.

EBIT
EBIT dropped to EUR -3 million due to lower revenue and the restructuring costs.

Brunel Europe (unaudited)

 

 

 

 

 

P&L amounts in EUR million

Q4 2016

Q4 2015

Change %

FY 2016

FY 2015

Change %

Revenue

110.1

112.9

-2%

437.8

415.3

5%

Gross Profit

33.9

37.1

-9%

137.9

133.4

3%

Gross Margin

30.8%

32.9%

31.5%

32.1%

Operating costs

25.8

23.8

8%

100.0

99.0

1%

EBIT

8.1

13.4

-39%

37.8

34.4

10%

EBIT %

7.4%

11.8%

8.6%

8.3%

 

Average directs

4,785

4,796

0%

4,719

4,561

3%

Average indirects

874

890

-2%

910

894

-3%

Ratio direct/indirect

5.5

5.4

5.4

5.1

Brunel Europe consists of Brunel Germany, Brunel Netherlands, Brunel Belgium, Brunel Czech Republic, Brunel Switzerland and Brunel Austria

Brunel Germany (unaudited)

 

 

 

 

 

P&L amounts in EUR million

Q4 2016

Q4 2015

Change %

FY 2016

FY 2015

Change %

Revenue

53.6

50.8

6%

210.5

196.4

7%

Gross Profit

18.9

18.4

3%

75.2

70.1

7%

Gross Margin

35.2%

36.2%

35.7%

35.7%

Operating costs

13.4

11.9

12%

50.5

50.7

0%

EBIT

5.5

6.5

-16%

24.7

19.4

27%

EBIT %

10.2%

12.8%

11.7%

9.9%

 

Average directs

2,272

2,139

6%

2,209

2,074

7%

Average indirects

377

426

-11%

402

439

-9%

Ratio direct/indirect

6.0

5.0

5.5

4.7

Revenue
Germany’s revenue has increased compared to the same period last year, despite three less working days in Q4. Revenue per working day increased by 11%.

The headcount development in 2016 is as follows:

Gross Profit
The decrease in gross margin of 1ppt compared to the same quarter last year is caused by three less working days, largely offset by a higher productivity.

Operating Costs

During the fourth quarter operating costs have increased compared to 2015. This is mainly a result of increased staff costs.

EBIT
EBIT for the quarter decreased by 15% to EUR 5.5 million, mainly due to the impact of the working days and increased overhead expenses.

Brunel Netherlands (unaudited)

 

 

 

 

 

P&L amounts in EUR million

Q4 2016

Q4 2015

Change %

FY 2016

FY 2015

Change %

Revenue

46.3

54.2

-14%

191.4

188.4

2%

Gross Profit

13.1

16.9

-22%

54.5

55.7

-2%

Gross Margin

28.3%

31.1%

28.5%

29.6%

Operating costs

10.4

9.9

5%

41.6

40.3

3%

EBIT

2.7

6.9

-61%

12.9

15.4

-16%

EBIT %

5.8%

12.8%

6.8%

8.2%

 

Average directs

2,184

2,317

-6%

2,178

2,143

2%

Average indirects

423

378

12%

395

370

7%

Ratio direct/indirect

5.2

6.1

5.5

5.8

Revenue
Revenue for The Netherlands was still impacted by the drop in headcount earlier this year due to the new law DBA, but also less growth in the second half of the year compared to last year and one less working day in Q4. Revenue per working day decreased by 13%.

The headcount development in 2016 is as follows:

Gross Profit
The downward trend of the gross margin due to price pressure and lower productivity continued in Q4. This quarter also had one less working day. The lower productivity is the result of continued training initiatives and pro active hiring.

Operating Costs
Operating costs are slightly higher than 2015 as a result of investments in our sales force and recruitment initiatives.

EBIT
Lower revenue at lower margins resulted in a decrease in EBIT of 61%.

Effective tax rate

In 2016 the effective tax rate increased from 33.6% to 56.2%, mainly as a result of an impairment of deferred tax assets of EUR 3.7 million. Due to the lower EBIT level, this impairment has a significant impact on our effective tax rate for 2016.

Cash position

The December 2016 cash balance amounted to EUR 149 million. Working capital as at 31 December is slightly higher than anticipated due to some short term projects in Energy towards the end of the year.

Dividend

We propose a dividend of EUR 0.40 per share.

Outlook

For The Netherlands we expect that the headcount growth we have resumed from July 2016 onwards will continue. This will result in revenue growth, despite the fact that we have started 2017 at a lower level than 2016. In Germany a new law will come in to effect in 2017. We expect that we have taken the appropriate measures and expect to see the growth continuing in 2017. Profitability in Germany will be impacted in 2017 by three less working days. For Energy we will see the full year impact of the decline in revenue in 2016, in combination with a further decline in headcount especially in the first half of 2017. As a result of our efforts towards new activities we expect that the revenue will be stabilizing in the second half of 2017 and we could even be returning to growth.

Jan Arie van Barneveld, CEO of Brunel International N.V.: “The ongoing crisis in the Oil & Gas sector made 2016 an exceptionally challenging year for us at Brunel. We’re now working hard to adapt the organization to these changing market conditions. First and foremost, by making ourselves more efficient, leaner and smarter in existing markets. At the same time, however, we do see new opportunities emerging for this part of the company. Both in terms of expanding our services, but also by entering markets outside Oil & Gas. However, it’ll be a while before we see these initiatives and developments reflected in our results. And although recovery of the market for Oil & Gas projects is inevitable, making any more specific predictions at this time is difficult. Except for one: as always, we’re confident about the resilience and entrepreneurial qualities of our people. And as a result, optimistic about the medium-to-long term developments and opportunities for this part of the business.

In Europe, overall growth and profit development in the region have been positive, but we have also seen considerable underlying differences in 2016. The Netherlands started the year very strongly, but then saw growth completely evaporate with the introduction of new legislation for engaging freelancers. The negative effects of which were luckily a one-off phenomenon. Meanwhile Germany managed in 2016 to accelerate even the impressive growth path achieved in 2015. But though the differences between countries are significant, the underlying results of all our European organizations in 2016 have once more been stronger across the region.

The robust organizations we have in Europe will form the basis for a return to growth. And, partly as a result of changes forced by the crisis, Energy will also soon be contributing to those growth figures. We live in times that are challenging, but also changing. And for strong organizations like Brunel, change always brings with it opportunities.”